The three most popular types of cigar cuts – punch, straight, and v-cut – all have distinct advantages and disadvantages.
Choosing the proper cut for your cigar can be daunting, depending on your smoking preferences and the type of cigar you have.
To help you navigate the intricate world of cigar cutting, this post explores the unique features of each cut.
Punch Cut: Clean and Efficient
A cigar punch creates a small, circular hole in the cap of your cigar. But is it the right choice for you?
Best for Bigger Ring Gauge Cigars
For bigger ring gauge cigars, especially those above 60 ring gauge, a punch cutter is preferable to a guillotine cutter.
A guillotine cutter exposes the surface area, and creating a proper seal for a good draw can be tiring.
Using a punch cutter allows for a cleaner incision, reducing the need for a complete seal.
The punch cut is the winner for very big ring gauge cigars, like Davidoff Yamasa, Rocky Patel The Edge Habano, and Gurkha Beast.
Less Risk of Unraveling
Since the punch only removes a small portion of the cap, it reduces the likelihood of the wrapper coming apart.
Concentrated Draw
The small hole created by the punch allows for a more focused and concentrated draw, enhancing the flavor experience.
Portability
Cigar punches are typically small and easy to carry, making them ideal for travel.
Many lighters nowadays are designed with a punch cutter, a very convenient combo to have with you on the road.
Consistent Cutting Depth
A cigar punch ensures you consistently cut the same depth with each use, providing a uniform experience across multiple cigars.
Very Convenient for Box-Pressed Cigars
For those who prefer punch cutters, the square surface of box-pressed cigars presents an opportunity for a clean and precise cut.
Since the surface area is not as round as a traditional cigar, a punch cutter can be easily presented and aligned for a perfect incision into the cigar.
This ensures that the wrapper stays intact and the flavors are concentrated.
Limited to Certain Cigar Sizes
Punches work best on larger ring gauge cigars. Smaller cigars may not have enough surface area for a clean punch.
For example, using a punch cutter for a 36-inch Lancero may crack the side of the cigar’s head, ruining your experience.
Can Clog During Smoking
The small hole created by the punch can sometimes become clogged with tar and residue, leading to a tight draw.
Difficulty in Cutting Figurado Cigars
The punch may struggle to wedge a hole in cigars with tapered shapes, like belicosos or torpedoes.
Limited Customization
A punch offers restricted cutting depth and size options, which may not appeal to those seeking a more personalized cutting experience.
Tips for Using a Cigar Punch Cutter
Rotate the punch cutter as you push it into the cigar’s cap to create a cleaner cut.
Experiment with different punch sizes to find the best choice for you and your preferred cigars.
Straight Cut: The Classic Choice
The straight cut, or guillotine cut, is the most traditional and standard cutting method cigar enthusiasts use.
It involves slicing off the entire cap of the cigar in one clean motion.
Versatility
Straight cuts work well with virtually any cigar shape or size, making it a reliable option for most smokers.
Easier Draw
Because the entire cap is removed, you’ll generally experience a smoother, more open draw.
Precision & Customizable Cutting Depth
With a sharp cutter, a straight cut can be very precise, ensuring a clean and even cut.
Also, you have more control over the depth of the cut, allowing you to tailor your smoking experience.
Works Well With Most Figurado Cigars
The straight cut can be used effectively on tapered cigars like torpedoes and belicosos, providing a clean, open draw.
Risk of Unraveling by Overcutting
A straight cut can cause the wrapper to unravel if not executed properly.
Inexperienced cigar smokers may accidentally cut too much off the cap, leading to an overly loose draw and a subpar smoking experience.
The Blades Should be Sharp
A dull cutter can lead to a jagged, uneven cut, so keeping your cutter sharp and well-maintained is essential.
There’s a Learning Curve
Achieving the perfect straight cut takes practice, which may be intimidating for beginners.
Tips for Using a Straight Cut
Cut just above the cigar’s shoulder (the curved part where the cap meets the body) to prevent the wrapper from unraveling.
Use a double-bladed guillotine cutter to ensure a clean, even cut from both sides.
V-Cut: The Stylish Alternative
The V-cut, or cat’s eye cut, creates a V-shaped notch in the cap of your cigar.
It’s an intriguing alternative to the straight cut, but is it the right fit for you?
Unique Draw and Enhanced Flavor Profile
The V-cut allows for a mix of concentrated and open draws, providing an exciting and enjoyable smoking experience.
The V-cut can help channel the smoke through a smaller opening, concentrating the flavors for a more intense smoking experience.
Works Well With Torpedo-Shaped Cigars
The V-cut is particularly well-suited for cigars with tapered ends, like torpedoes and pyramids.
Precise and Clean Cut
The V-cut offers an accurate and clean cut thanks to its bowl shape design and spring-loaded button.
Different from traditional cutters, it is impossible to over-cut with the V-cut.
This makes it an excellent choice for those who tend to be clumsy.
Limited to Specific Cigar Sizes
Like the punch, the V-cut might be challenging for smaller cigars.
Not Ideal for Flat-Capped Cigars
V-cuts may not provide an optimal smoking experience for cigars with a flat cap, like parejos. However, this might be a personal preference.
More Challenging to Clean the Tool
Due to its unique shape, a V-cutter may require extra care and attention when cleaning and maintaining it.
Tips for Using a V-Cut
Apply gentle but firm pressure when using a V-cutter to ensure a clean, even cut.
Experiment with different angles and depths to find your ideal V-cut for your preferred cigars.
